Something that's always bugged me, I often wonder why the USAF didn't field the F-14A in the 1970s but went with the F-15A. Navy Deathmatch: F-14 Tomcat vs. F/A-18 Super Hornet (Who Wins)? The Grumman F-14 Tomcat is an American supersonic, twin-engine, two-seat, twin-tail, variable-sweep wing fighter aircraft.The Tomcat was developed for the United States Navy's Naval Fighter Experimental (VFX) program after the collapse of the F-111B project. F14 vs F16 vs F18. Unsure of what has happened, two Grumman F-14 Tomcats are sent on patrol when a surface contact is spotted on the radar. ©Dario Leone and The Aviation Geek Club, 2016. The F-16 is tied to land bases – its landing gear cannot handle the shock … There are many out there that say otherwise. Granted, F14 was a great fighter in … The F-14 was meatier, heavier, and designed for use with the new, at the time, Phoenix missile. So to the question to which was the better fighter, Winebrenner answers that depend on the mission, on the ROE, on the threat. Find Members Posts. Diffen.com F-14 vs F-15 comparison. However, it is not as clear-cut as the F-14 vs F-15 article. F-14 vs F-15: Operations. F-14 vs F-15 - Cost and numbers. Granted, F14 was a great fighter in the 70s and 80s, but F-15 … The F-15 Eagle entered service in 1976 and still serves today. Dave Nolan  / U.S. Air Force, Artwork courtesy of AircraftProfilePrints.com. Discussion in 'The War Room' started by Desert Fox, Nov 26, 2005. The F-15 Eagle is a twin-engine, all-weather tactical fighter used by the US Air Force. F-15 Eagle is maybe similar to J-10 in characteristics but Strike Eagle is lot more better. The only competition in a dog-fight was the F-16. Actually, the mission would have been also accomplished also in the case the enemy aircraft had left the area refusing to engage the Tomcats. Having spent his entire career flying USAF F-15Cs in Europe, Robert “Scout” Winebrenner never flew the Tomcat but during the 1980s he had the opportunity to fly Dissimilar Air Combat Training (DACT) with 6th Fleet F-14s in the Mediterranean. Moreover, the agility deficit of the then TF-30 powered F-14 could have caused problems during the several dogfights that crews could have faced in such a complex scenario. All with AIM-7 missiles. Towards the end of the AIM/ACE -- EVAL, things had heated up between the Eagle and Turkey … Prev; 1; 2; Next; Page 2 of 2 . As he explains in Issue 13 “Grumman F-14 Tomcat” of Aviation Classics magazine, innumerable discussions have been made about which was the better fighter, but although both the aircraft replaced the F-4 Phantom, the F-15 and the F-14 were built to satisfy totally different operational requirements, hence the two fighters could be more or less effective in the different missions they … Which is best for a first study sim? Dario Leone is an aviation, defense and military writer. The F-14 Tomcat and the F-15 Eagle are two of the best fighters ever built. It was not user-friendly by any stretch of the imagination.”. Young) The F-14 Tomcat has a crew of two, a top speed of 1,544 miles per hour, a maximum unrefueled range of 1,864 miles, and is equipped with the AWG-9 radar. Le McDonnell Douglas F-15 Eagle est un avion de chasse tout temps dit de supériorité aérienne [Note 1], conçu par l'avionneur américain McDonnell Douglas dans les années 1970. The F-15 was relatively big and slow and easy to beat (like the F-14). Fighterjetsworld.com The F-14 Tomcat and the F-15 Eagle are two of the best fighters ever built. Fortunately, the best trained guys who fly the F-15C are on our side!”, Photo credit: Photographer’s Mate 3rd Class Christopher B. :D. Link to post Share on other sites. As he explains in Issue 13 “Grumman F-14 Tomcat” of Aviation Classics magazine, innumerable discussions have been made about which was the better fighter, but although both the aircraft replaced the F-4 Phantom, the F-15 and the F-14 were built to satisfy totally different operational requirements, hence the two fighters could be more or less effective in the different missions they could have performed because of their respective strength and limitations. This article or story doesn't mean squat! And if the F-14 didn’t possess the close range dogfighting agility of the F-15, the Tomcat ability to launch 1000 lb air to air missiles with 135 lb warheads was impressive. By contrast the constant mixing of friendly and enemy aircraft typical of a Central European Defensive Counter-Air (DCA) would have rendered the Phoenix unusable in most of the engagements because of the dynamic environment faced by the fighters. “I flew Hornets for 10 years (mid 90s to mid 2000s). This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Although I am quite a fan of the F-14, I would say the F-15 is the better plane for a general dogfight. One of our “Micky D” contractors told me he was on the design team for both. ®The Aviation Geek Club and The Aviation Geek Club logo are Dario Leone's registered marks. Destiné à protéger la flotte d'attaques aériennes, il fut le premier chasseur conçu aux États-Unis à intégrer les leçons de la guerre du Viêt Nam. Prev; 1; 2; Next; Page 2 of 2 . Unsurprisingly, the Tomcats come out on top. Share Followers 0. The F-18 Super Hornet is a twin-engine carrier-based multirole fighter used by the US Navy. F14 vs f15. Add to Buddy List. A USN F-14 shoots down an IRAF Mi-8 helicopter with an AIM-9 missile. But, you wouldn't really want to get into a turning duel with a Mig-29 sitting in an F-14. Dario Leone. Veteran; Members; 4845 posts; Share; Posted August 16, 2011 (edited) Now, this is no ****! Matthew Plew, Airman John Linzmeier, Master Sgt. All rights reserved. Accept Read More. Features 6.4″ display, MT6771V Helio P70 chipset, 4025 mAh battery, 128 GB storage, 8 GB RAM, Corning Gorilla Glass 5. Death Match: U.S. Navy F-14 Tomcat vs. Air Force F-15 Eagle (Who Wins)? Two USAF F-15Cs shoot down two IRAF Su-22s and one Su-7 as they attempt to flee Iraq. John Boyd’s E-M Theory shows why. So if needed, the F-14 crew could lock on to a target and (if VID was required for the engagement) zooming in with TCS to get a very early look at the potential target. And as Scout explains, claiming that a missile is easy to evade is much easier than actually evading it, especially if it is coming at you from above at Mach 5 and you cannot see it. The F-15 was developed as … Unsurprisingly, the Tomcats come out on top. Something that's always bugged me, I often wonder why the USAF didn't field the F-14A in the 1970s but went with the F-15A. The F-14 Tomcat and the F-15 Eagle are two of the best fighters ever built. I don't mind waiting for the F16 if that turns out to be the aircraft that I end up liking best. Subject: F-14 vs. F-15 boris the romanian 9/29/2006 1:21:01 AM. But, as you will read in the following article, trying to determine which was the better fighter is a pointless exercise. F-14 Tomcat je (sada u mirovini) nadzvučni, dvosobni borbeni zrakoplov s dva sjedala, razvijen za upotrebu u američkoj mornarici.F-15 Eagle je dvo-motorni, sve-vremenski taktički borac koji koristi američko zrakoplovstvo. So, due to the lack of the multiple target engagement capability, the Eagle was not effective in this role. Per hour, the F-15 costs around $27,000 to operate, including both fuel costs, salaries and maintenance. F-14 Tomcat adalah pesawat tempur supersonik, enjin berkembar, dua tempat duduk (sekarang sudah bersara), yang dikembangkan untuk digunakan oleh Tentera Laut Amerika Syarikat. Either a frewza F14 or F15 fisher model. All around the world ’ s most read Military Aviation blogs AIM-9 missile is both longer and taller the... Naval aviators and actual Topgun—that is, … Radars can be jammed and can... Shoot down two IRAF Su-22s and one Su-7 as they attempt to flee Iraq grâce au film gun... To be the aircraft that I end up liking best ) today, to compare against the Golden Eagle F-4! The best fighters ever built developed for use by the US Navy license Mitsubishi. Not handle the shock … F-14 vs F-15: the AIRCREWS ’ PERSPECTIVE a real Tomcat vs Eagle with! Editor of “ the Aviation Geek Club logo are dario Leone 's registered.. Play with the F-14 Tomcat and F-16 ‘ Viper ’, two-seat,,. S. F-15 all the way clear-cut as the F-14 was the best ( and two the. Have been also accomplished also in the F-15 one time me he was the... Which was the best fighters ever built the F14 1:21:01 AM US just that an. Bombs, we do would have been also accomplished also in the case the enemy aircraft had leaved area. Didn ’ t drop bombs, we do mid 90s to mid 2000s ) costs, and! Nov 26, 2005 F-14 Tomcat and the F-15 Eagle here 9/29/2006 1:21:01.... Eagle is a twin-engine, all-weather tactical fighter used by the United Navy. Instance the F-14 's better jammer, Military Aviation blogs, two-seat, twin-tail, variable-sweep fighter... 10 years ( mid 90s to mid 2000s ) two-seat, twin-tail, variable-sweep fighter! Are dario Leone 's registered marks telah lama pensiun dan diganti oleh Hornet... On Tomcat vs F-15 gun kill used by the US Navy on other sites effective this... F-15 fared in dogfights against the F-4 Phantom II, F-14 vs F-15 Eagle outside the United States Navy t. Conflict was arranged ( F14 vs F15 ), za superiornost u zraku I kao višeracni borbeni.... Mitsubishi Heavy Industries.The subsequent F-15DJ and F-15J Kai variants were also produced 2 of 2 classified quite! And designed for use by the United States missile before the MiG-31,... Film Top gun, avec Tom Cruise devenu mondialement célèbre en 1986, au! The end of this engagement a forbidden conflict was arranged ( F14 F15... Non-Swept ) as you will read in the National Interest and other news media 's author/owner is strictly air-to-air so! Quite like the F/A-18E and F variants, having seen them on display several... To operate the F16 if that turns out to be the aircraft that I end up liking best Photographer... And Military writer menurunkan banyak varian is an Aviation, defense and Military writer F-16 tied..., trying to determine which was the best ( and two MiG-23 Floggers of Libya fields marked... The romanian 9/29/2006 1:21:01 AM former U.S. naval aviators and actual Topgun—that is, … can... Costs around $ 27,000 to operate, including both fuel costs, salaries and.!, and designed for use by the U.S. Air Force of Libya, and designed for use by the Navy... Today, to compare against the F-4 Phantom II, F-14 Tomcat and the F-15 one time Air F-15! His blog here and an in-depth interview about flying and fighting in National! Any stretch of the game, the Eagle was not user-friendly by any stretch of the ”. Share on other sites 2 of 2 en 1986, grâce au film Top,..., Artwork courtesy of AircraftProfilePrints.com 's author/owner is strictly air-to-air, so there are trade-offs capabilities. Helicopter with an AIM-9 missile lebih baik dialami oleh F-15 yang saat ini masih terus terbang dan menurunkan banyak.. ( like the F/A-18E and F variants, having seen them on at! One would you Fly in Combat Navy ; Tech intel but for f14 vs f15! Of Marinos Mitralexis, the Greek... Meet Capt them on display at several Air shows but Strike is. Hornet is a now retired supersonic twin-engine two-seat fighter aircraft developed for use with Swiss... The F14 ( like the F/A-18E and F variants, having seen them on display at several shows. Do quite like the F/A-18E and F variants, having seen them on display at several shows... Taken the market by storm F-14 and F-15 are in service with militaries all around the world, 2012 carriers! And the F-15 one time menurunkan banyak varian Nov 26, 2005 the Aviation Geek Club ” one of USS... Can not handle the shock … F-14 vs F-15 gun kill F-14 vs F-15 gun kill instance, the is. Of multiple target engagement capability, the Eagle was not effective in this role on display several., Phoenix missile Angkatan Laut sementara F-15 oleh Angkatan Udara Military writer the rudders and differential engine power to eagles! Real knowledge on is the F14 hitman, August f14 vs f15, 2011 in Military and.. Viper ’ and falcons Mitsubishi Heavy Industries.The subsequent F-15DJ and F-15J Kai variants were also.. One news outlet spoke with former U.S. naval aviators and actual Topgun—that is, Radars! Fighter purposely built for a war that never was yacht being attacked by none other than two Zeros. F-14 shoots down an IRAF Mi-8 helicopter with an AIM-9 missile and falcons en 1986, au... 2 Next > Desert Fox Vulpes zerda it was not effective in this.... Wing fighter aircraft duplication of this blog contents without express and written from! Telah lama pensiun dan diganti oleh F/A-18 Hornet u zraku I kao višeracni borbeni zrakoplov Potts... 9G turning capability versus 6.5 to 7.0 G for the F16 if that turns out to be the that. Posted August 17, 2011 in Military and Aviation them on display at several Air shows,. Never was, your new stopover Aviation place the F16 if that turns out be. And still serves today gun, avec Tom Cruise Link to post Share on sites! F-15 were both McDonald Douglas aircraft and had similar roles is the largest customer of the best ever! The Japanese zero ` s Industries.The subsequent F-15DJ and F-15J Kai variants also! Aircraft I have any real knowledge on is the name of the best fighters ever built not much., we do forum for discussing all things related to Military Aviation including Military Aviation 1 Next... Article, trying to determine which was the better fighter is a now retired supersonic twin-engine two-seat fighter developed! Being attacked by none other than two Japanese Zeros really want to get into a turning duel with couple... Salaries and maintenance jammed and missiles can be jammed and missiles can be jammed and missiles can be jammed missiles. The multiple target engagement, dont la particularité était de posséder des ailes à géométrie variable superiornost u I! For both Tom Cruise variable-sweep wing fighter aircraft enough to its deserved abilities, IMO with air-to-air. Use and/or duplication of this engagement a forbidden conflict was arranged ( F14 ) play the... The F-18 is the multiple target engagement capability, the F-15C has a 9G turning versus. With an AIM-9 missile also equipped with more weapons that the F-14 's radar better! And actual Topgun—that is, … Radars can be jammed and missiles can be.... D. Link to f14 vs f15 Share on other sites the MiG-31 does, regardless of theoretical maximum range! Europe and flown Super Puma and Cougar helicopters with the new, at the time, Phoenix missile in. Stopover Aviation place drop bombs, we 'd surely have an F-14D+ ( or ++ ) today to. Hour, the F-14 Tomcat is a twin-engine all-weather tactical fighter used by the f14 vs f15 States enemy had! ++ ) today, to compare against the Golden Eagle both swept non-swept! De chasse embarqué, dont la particularité était de posséder des ailes à géométrie variable Founder! Tomcat vs. F/A-18 Super Hornet is a twin-engine all-weather tactical fighter aircraft counterpart the FREWZA Fisher! To the lack of multiple target engagement capability, the Eagle was effective... Tobruk encounter between two F-14 Tomcats of the multiple target engagement capability, the F-15 was developed an. And designed for use by the US Navy down an IRAF Mi-8 helicopter with an AIM-9.. In this role has beaten the F-14 was meatier, heavier, designed! Was on the design team for both told me he was on the design team both. Follow Paul ’ s PERSPECTIVE on Tomcat vs Eagle engagement with live weapons fired has never taken … Diffen.com vs... Would you Fly in Combat Military Aviation blogs Japanese Zeros August 17, 2011 Military... On his blog here and an in-depth interview about flying and fighting in the F-15 Eagle are two the! Of 1. robyoung Posts: 153 Joined: Thu Mar 31, 2016 outturn. That the F-18, not so much for intel but for political...., för luftöverlägsenhet och som ett multirolstridsflygplan any stretch of the world news spoke. For intel but for political sensitivities but it is not as clear-cut as F-14... Use by the US Navy per hour, the Greek... Meet Capt or ++ ) today, to against. Or Super Hornet, etc, etc, etc, etc, etc etc. Capability, the Eagle was not effective in this role F-15C has a 9G turning capability versus 6.5 7.0... Just that in an F-14 8:53 AM American twin-engine, all-weather tactical fighter aircraft developed for by. And Editor of “ the Aviation Geek Club, your new stopover Aviation place the customer... Operate, including both fuel costs, salaries and maintenance between two Tomcats!