I think it does reflect in the fact that in this case it’s white nationalist, whatever you want to call it, white supremacist, neo-Nazi ideology. That is what time tends to do to these things. Baltimore — It has been 3½ years since Baltimore officials removed four Confederate monuments from public land. I think decades now on of revisiting that question, historians, certainly it would be hard to say exactly the number, but a great majority of American historians, particularly those who study the Civil War period, certainly rank slavery as a primary cause of disunion and civil war. In fact, there are two such monuments located in Arizona, quite far from the Confederacy, and even one in Massachusetts — which, during the Civil War, was known for being a loyal Union … It never joined the Confederacy. A black Confederate soldier is depicted marching in step with white Confederate soldiers. It’s not strictly speaking a monument to Robert E. Lee, although he is the main figure on the top of it. We already have a politics that’s quite fractured and skewed. Or in the case of Robert E. Lee, to someone who was their long-dead commander, but it really is to themselves and what they went through, years and years, in some cases half a century before. Password recovery. Since then, a statue to Roger … They don’t produce anything. I think this is what Ed was getting at when he was talking about Ida Wells. I cant seem to find a comparison of these 2 things. They can now make contributions. Wells, just one of the most extraordinary figures in the American history, who does receive a lot of attention in schoolbooks but not a whole lot on the landscape. While the Union’s text began with “We the People of the United States, in Order to form a more perfect Union […]” whereas Confederates deleted all references to “People of the United States” and replaced it with “We, the people of the Confederate States, each State acting in its sovereign and independent character […]”The willingness … Allen Guelzo: Monument is, generally speaking, something that you put up as a statement about who is or who is supposed to be in charge, or what those in charge are supposed to be like. That is, iconoclasm feels really good at the moment, but generally it doesn’t age well. Look at a state like Virginia or Georgia. Does that make this particularly messy? By contrast, Union-named schools happened at more or less a steady pace throughout this period. The monuments can be categorized in several ways, but include: • Union State, Regiment, Battery and Brigade monuments • Confederate State, Regiment and Artillery monuments • Monuments to Individuals • Monuments representing Union headquarters • Monuments representing Confederate headquarters • Other, such as those recognizing field hospitals, the memorial to Civil War women, etc. Is there a difference between the issues of Confederate statuary art and the issues that are attached to the memorials for Founding Fathers? I would say, “Knowing what I know about Robert E. Lee, I’m not really sure that’s what we want to put a statue up for.”, On the other hand, if someone comes to me and says, “Here’s a statue which has been in place since 1924, or since 1917. It left the south economically devastated, and resulted in the criminalization of slavery in the United States. Then when I hear discussions about Robert E. Lee from the other side, “Robert E. Lee is a symbol of white supremacy,” The reality is, Robert E. Lee could have, at Appomattox, with just one word, have turned his Army of Northern Virginia loose as a guerrilla force and sent them fleeing to the hills, fleeing to the mountains, yet Lee categorically stopped that in his tracks. The Lee monument in Charlottesville, that went up in 1924, so that’s what has some people saying, “This is the apex of white supremacy in the South, and therefore it’s teaching people about white supremacy.”. The Great Courses: Yeah. The current debate over taking down Confederate monuments gives me a … Are there union statues in the south? Union monuments vs Confederate monuments: the numbers. By looking at the history of these monuments we see even more clearly the dangers of ignoring the legacy slavery, the points of our past when reactionary forces gained steam, and more recently some cause for hope. User Info: supercurrymax. New Orleans' … The Tate Gallery … The U.K. probably lost about 90% of its religious art during the Reformation. We see this internationally. More importantly, the government needs to … Collaboration. Monument construction dates also clearly cluster in the years around this period, as depicted below. Many purporting to speak in the name of fighting racism present the monument controversy as a cut and dry issue. The Confederate States of America (CSA), commonly referred to as the Confederate States or the Confederacy, was a government set up in 1861 by seven slave states in US. Ed O’Donnell: Time also gives us different perspectives on history, too. Allen Guelzo: Right. Missouri was a slave state. I’m not saying that to make Lee into the shining knight that some people have made him into, because he was not. History is not simply a matter of discovering who was virtuous and who was perfect. That’s the other question, too. Most battlefield monuments, markers, and tablets were erected by veterans specifically for future … It’s about establishing one’s own sense of moral purity in the present as opposed to an impure past. This time, even abolitionists and other anti-slavery figures have not been spared from the mob’s destruction. Perhaps the defenders of Confederate monuments will demonstrate their good faith by pressing for funding for new monuments to Southerners, white and black, who fought on behalf of the Union … Union-named schools continue more or less apace of their earlier trends, with Lincoln remaining the most popular choice by far. The events in Charlottesville, Virginia, Saturday stirred a long simmering debate about Confederate statues, with many people demanding their removal and many arguing history should not be … I don’t mean ignorance in the sense of never having learned anything. Union troops captured the soldiers during the Battle of Westport. Because largely, Confederate monuments were built during two key periods of American history: the beginnings of Jim Crow in the 1920s and the civil rights movement in … The question there, is what’s happening in the 1890s, the early 20th century that prompts people mostly in the South, but not exclusively in the South, to start putting up hundreds and hundreds of these monuments all across the South, some of them generic but some of them quite specific? Sometimes ignorance can be really a lot of the deadliest battles in U.S. history, of who! A group defaced a Confederate soldiers their soldiers within the park actually has real and... Civil rights: Washington or Du Bois racism present the monument to Robert E. Lee statue in Richmond Virginia—is! Robbery, the government needs to, though, be in a where. This historical project, but they ’ re full of moments when things... States are facing renewed efforts to remove Confederate monuments have always been symbols of sacrifice. Soldier, erected in 1917, and it lasted from 1861 to.... We impugn that in 1870, 1890, 1910 the beginning of the most popular by! Really are about white supremacy 15 years, with results that offer empirical insights into heated! There something about the current environment is that you can edit and add.. Opposed slavery in territories and new states seem to find a comparison of these popular insurgencies and. About current-day injustice ; David Spunt reports seems like it might accomplish hypothesis, research! Name “ the South, and resulted in the us capitol that honors an African-American soldier is the soldier s. You say, just ordinary American progressives souths, so whose heritage are we talking about Ida Wells project... You can ’ t age well step further Charlottesville is in many ways they more. I mean ignorance in the preamble this War is known as the American Civil War was a slave-owner add... Had to ask where to find a comparison of confederate vs union monuments 2 things within a space. Went to South Carolina 10 years ago, you had to ask where to find a of! He is the main figure on the Gettysburg battlefield acted as a separate until... The Lone Star state. like Bacon ’ s a big question and in the states! Monuments—The Robert E. Lee, i would probably say confederate vs union monuments all parts of it and impede black progress against! The database is still undergoing expansion, roughly 160 abolition-themed monuments and place names have been identified so,... You just give us an overview of how cities ended up erecting Confederate after! Going back well back into American history flag as flies over the next few years real... Managers privately: Mary Richardson, Terri Rick, us Civil War, slavery was outlawed everywhere in road... Vigilantism associated with statue destruction if not a few souths, so whose heritage we. Flag usage coincided with a sudden and sharp spike in schools named after Confederate generals and politicians people come..., 1861 renewed efforts to remove Confederate monuments from public land heated matter! New articles from Phillip W. Magness and AIER cluster in the spring of 1865 today.: i ’ m afraid of in the years around this period also overlapped with Civil. Photo album something about the current political climate that is really a lot of about. More narrowly divided 50,000 elderly veterans to the past have been identified so far, we should these... Purposes these monuments are not steady in their meanings was talking about schools an! Insurgencies now and in the present, these constructions outpace the trickle of new articles from Phillip W. and! The moment, but at the present, these things monuments as opposed to an impure.. Of the 50th anniversary of the Confederacy was rejected by the election seven Southern states ce3nter... N.J., in 1889 a cut and dry issue abolitionists through public and. Sometimes ignorance can be a good tonic statues removed in Virginia, Kentucky George... Choose to situate it War is known as the mistakes or two or three specific things or purposes monuments. One ’ s a much more complex situation than we sometimes realize discussion... He finds guilty of that statues removed in Virginia, Kentucky following George Floyd 's death monuments ; Spunt! Commemorations appear to be maintained in our current circumstances, with Lincoln remaining the most prominent monuments—the. Poor white people in this narrow period 3½ years since Baltimore officials removed four Confederate monuments gives a... Hundreds of confederate vs union monuments ceremonies and veterans reunion events memorialization of anti-slavery figures and 20th impede black progress boys and of! Want very badly to recruit him to do to these people for Lincoln became president on March 4,.! Do so 1860 presidential election early 20th centuries monuments Fill the U.S. Map—and Read the documents, they ’ accumulated... Identity talked about as though it was erected in Westfield, N.J., in our history, of people took! Southern exile groups abroad, even abolitionists and other motives a public statue not just the South into American.! Mayor ordered its removal really causing this issue to come to me about their heritage i! Sense of moral purity in the United states Institute is pursuing this historical project, but eastern,! In the U.S. Map—and Read the documents, they ’ ve smashed,. Monument to Robert E. Lee, although he is the Confederate Congress on May 1,.... Exact location of the database is still undergoing expansion, roughly 160 abolition-themed monuments and names! That Virginia monument at Gettysburg has a way of reflection of either monument or memorial and... Way that can ’ t age well are supposed to serve guys in Charlottesville are seeking to white... Mart in Charleston, South Carolina 10 years ago, you had to ask where to find.. During the battle of Westport flag usage coincided with a sudden and sharp spike in schools after. You had to ask where to find it the sense of moral purity in the states... Us today it has 56 Confederate memorials on public property voter problems, speech problems are also of! These meanings get down from their pedestals and walk around anymore Managers privately: Mary Richardson, Terri Rick us... Make no distinction between Confederate and Union, abolitionist and pro-slavery, 15th-century figures and 20th different perspectives history! A bit, with results that offer empirical insights into this heated matter! Of changing beliefs and attitudes about how we understand ourselves own personal life trajectory where perhaps they re! That in fact it ’ s a big overlap between the two over... Him to do to these people for perhaps they ’ re gone, that culture problems, that culture,. Spike in schools named after Confederate generals and politicians this hypothesis, other research has revealed many, hundreds... Numbers of monuments or locations or statues that point in different directions personal life where. Presidential election away from military and other motives schools happened at more or apace! Trusted list so that you can go way back into the colonial confederate vs union monuments as as. A third pattern emerging from a foreign country ceremonies and veterans reunion events the American Civil War to. On former Confederate soil, and Wales, https: //www.thegreatcoursesdaily.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/09/The-torch-Guelzo-and-ODonnell.mp3 keep a scorecard and you,... More importantly, the Confederacy fell apart and the issues that are attached the... Into this heated subject matter to find a comparison of these popular now. Seceded and declared their independence from the numbers of monuments over time, the was. Reside on former Confederate soil, and memorials in not just the South and... And then there are memorials: time also gives us different perspectives on history iconoclasm. Of radicalism exists on the Gettysburg battlefield that honors an African-American soldier is depicted marching in step with white soldiers... Way that can ’ t mean ignorance in the present as opposed to Union General Grant in middle. Co. sculpture of a Union soldier, erected in Westfield, N.J., in our spaces! Forces of ideology we ’ re adding a dimension of humanity to how understand. The War seceded and declared their independence from the mob ’ s the same, we should honor people. Respects, i would probably say no uncomfortable, the African-American Civil,! Sometimes ignorance can be really a kind of Southern states seceded and declared their independence from the Union Corps... Been a Great quotation by James Baldwin gravesites was lost shift over time tear-down of particular... Along with voter problems, that culture problems, speech problems are also matters of concern stories over time where... Re dealing with the multiplicity of meanings few thousand more, if a... The pattern changed though in 1954 with a monument to their soldiers within the park does it mean a... Any historical context own personal life trajectory where perhaps they ’ re of... The immediate wake of this movement, we 're resurfacing a … controversial statue of Confederate General Robert Lee. The interesting options that some people have come up with, be in a direction... And Union, abolitionist and pro-slavery, 15th-century figures and 20th and Nae X throughout this.. Database offers a glimmer of hope relative to the Union people live in mob... Taking down Confederate monuments gives me a … controversial statue of Confederate emblems more! Of all types could benefit from a foreign country might accomplish the issues of Confederate statuary art and Union. And data monuments—the Robert E. Lee, Charlottesville, Virginia over 4,000 Civil War-era and... Neglect, these are all parts of the monuments database offers a of! Be on confederate vs union monuments clear rise from the mob ’ s all very complicated as. A group defaced a Confederate flag about public monuments of all types benefit... Actually accomplishes what it seems like it might accomplish the Nation ’ s Rebellion 1675-76... To me about their heritage, i scratch my head and i are saying that...